Exclusive Content & Downloads from ASQ

An Evaluation of the Laboratory Ranking Test

Summary: The laboratory ranking test is a nonparametric procedure that W.J. Youden recommended in 1963 for identifying outlying laboratories in collaborative studies. Though potential problems with the performance of this test have been noted by Youden and others, its use still is being promoted. One problem with the test is that its critical values were developed for a different application and do not allow for the between-laboratory variation ordinarily observed in collaborative studies. This paper presents a quantitative evaluation of the impact of between-laboratory variation and other factors on the performance of the laboratory ranking test. The results document some of the test's shortcomings, including its propensity to identify unexceptional laboratories as outliers.

Anyone with a subscription, including Site and Enterprise members, can access this article.

Other Ways to Access content:

Join ASQ

Join ASQ as a Full member. Enjoy all the ASQ member benefits including access to many online articles.

Subscribe to Journal of Quality Technology

Access this and ALL OTHER Journal of Quality Technology online articles. You'll also receive the print version by mail.

  • Topics: Laboratory
  • Keywords: Interlaboratory comparisons,Statistical tests,Outliers,Estimation
  • Author: Elder, Robert S.
  • Journal: Journal of Quality Technology